Internal · Dues Comparator
Admin · Dues Comparator

Dues / Assessment Benchmark

How our 18 properties' assessments stack up against comparable Tallahassee condos and HOAs. Per-unit, per-square-foot, and per-amenity-tier. Defensible context for boards setting next year's budget — "we're 11% below market" is a much easier conversation than "trust us."

$2,168Plaza Tower avg / mo
−11%vs Tallahassee high-rise comp
$1.84PSF / month · PT
42Comps in dataset

Plaza Tower vs. Tallahassee high-rise comps

Property
Year built
# units
Avg / mo
$ / sf / mo
Reserve %
vs PT
The Plaza on PalmerTallahassee · Midtown
2018
112
$2,840
$2.42
92%
Twelve Oaks TowerTallahassee · Capital East
2014
96
$2,580
$2.18
88%
Adams PlaceTallahassee · Downtown
2011
74
$2,420
$2.04
96%
Plaza Tower (us · CMG)Tallahassee · Midtown · 2009
2009
84
$2,168
$1.84
98%
baseline
Magnolia Heights CondoTallahassee · Killearn
2007
62
$1,940
$1.62
72%
St. Augustine PlaceTallahassee · Northeast
2005
58
$1,820
$1.54
68%

Reading: Plaza Tower assessment is on the lower end vs. modern Midtown high-rises but reserve funding is best-in-class at 98%. Magnolia & St. Augustine assess less but are 70%-funded — they'll need a special assessment within 5 yrs.

Why we look the way we do

Reserve discipline pays

Plaza Tower is among the lowest-assessment, highest-reserve-funded properties in Tallahassee. Treasurer M. Hou's 5-yr funding push is the reason.

98% funded

vs market avg 78%

Insurance is the headwind

Florida hardening pushes carriers up. Travelers proposing +10.5% for next renewal — every comp is feeling this.

+10.5%

market avg +12.4%

Concierge is differentiated

PT runs 24/7 staffed front desk. Only Twelve Oaks Tower matches. Adams + Plaza on Palmer are 6 AM – midnight with security only overnight.

24/7

2 of 6 comp peers

Deferred-maintenance risk

Magnolia Heights and St. Augustine are low-assessment because they are under-funding reserves. Special assessments coming → owner-flight risk.

SA likely

2 properties at risk

Per-sf efficiency

Plaza Tower's $1.84 PSF/mo beats every newer comp by $0.20–$0.58. Older building, but reflects efficient ops + tight bidding.

$1.84

market avg $2.08

Special assessments avoided

PT's last special assessment was 2018 for roof phase 1. Reserve discipline has averted 2 cycles since. Comps average 1 SA every 4 years.

8 yrs

since last PT SA

Garden-style HOA comps · Lakes at Killearn

Property
Year built
# units
Avg / mo
Includes
Reserve %
vs LK
Bull Run EstatesTallahassee · NE
1998
184
$184
landscape
82%
Killearn Estates HOATallahassee · NE
1985
1,840
$148
landscape
74%
Lakes at Killearn (us)Tallahassee · NE
2002
148
$132
landscape · pool · clubhouse
94%
baseline
Killearn Lakes PlantationTallahassee · NE
1990
2,420
$98
landscape
62%

Methodology & data sources

Public filings

Sunbiz registered agent + Leon County Property Appraiser parcel data. Estoppel certs from active closings (with closing-attorney consent) feed real assessment numbers, not advertised numbers.

MLS resale data

Residential MLS includes monthly assessment and any open special assessments. We refresh monthly. Adjusts for assessment changes mid-year.

Reserve-funding sourcing

Reserve % from §718.111(13) annual financial reports filed with DBPR · publicly accessible. SIRS adequacy from §718.301(4)(p) study summaries when available.

Apples-to-apples adjustments

Adjusts for amenity tier, age, building height, concierge hours, master insurance scope. A garden-style without pool isn't compared to one with.

Refresh cadence

Quarterly refresh. Boards see trailing 4 quarters in a chart, with current cycle highlighted. Budget Builder pulls market context into the variance memo automatically.

Privacy

Only aggregate, public, or owner-permissioned data. No CMG-internal numbers shared into the comp dataset across associations. Boards see their own + market — never the other 17 associations' detail.

Where this shows up

Budget Builder variance memo, board-mobile portal "Finance" tab, annual letter to owners explaining the next year's assessment, prospect-board recruitment conversations ("we're below market and best-funded — that's why I serve").

References

§718.111(13) annual financial report · §718.116(8) estoppel · DBPR public records · Leon County Property Appraiser API · Tallahassee MLS data feed.